AdvertiseDonate
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
The latest from the cities that shape the country.
Central Wire Live · 5825 Delmonico Dr, Suite 320, Colorado Springs, CO 80919

Murdaugh defense requests dismissal of 2021 murder indictments

Attorneys allege the lead investigator misled the grand jury regarding blood spatter and weapon evidence.

By Luis Hoffmann ·

Illustration for: Murdaugh defense requests dismissal of 2021 murder indictments
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Attorneys for Alex Murdaugh filed a motion on Friday, November 13, asking a South Carolina judge to dismiss the original indictments for the 2021 killings of his wife and son. The defense team contends that David Owen, the State Law Enforcement Division agent who led the investigation, provided false testimony to the Colleton County grand jury. This legal challenge occurs while Murdaugh prepares for a new murder trial scheduled for April.

Judge Debra McCaslin will hear the motion. The South Carolina Supreme Court vacated Murdaugh’s 2023 convictions and life sentence after determining that a court clerk improperly influenced jurors. Even if the judge grants the dismissal, prosecutors can seek new indictments as soon as next month. Defense lawyers have stated they will not oppose new charges, so a ruling in Murdaugh’s favor may not delay the retrial.

The core of the defense argument relies on discrepancies in Owen’s grand jury statements. The defense claims Owen told the grand jury that blood spatter was found on the T-shirt Murdaugh wore during the killings. A preliminary report from state agents indicated no such stains existed, and prosecutors did not present that evidence at the first trial. Owen also testified that guns on the property contained a specific ammunition arrangement matching the shots that killed Paul Murdaugh, a description the defense calls inaccurate.

Prosecutors argue that other evidence sufficiently supported the original charges. They maintain that any error in Owen’s testimony did not reflect bad faith. The state pointed to a video recorded by Paul Murdaugh in which his father’s voice was audible at the scene, contradicting Murdaugh’s denial of his presence. Prosecutors also cited the family’s mounting debts and the impending discovery of Murdaugh’s financial fraud as motives for the murders.

Defense attorneys have consistently argued that physical evidence linking Murdaugh to the shootings is limited. No DNA or blood spatter was detected on Murdaugh or his clothing, even though the victims were shot at close range with high-powered weapons. The firearms used in the killings were never recovered from the property. The defense points to these gaps as evidence that the original indictments were built on weak foundations.

Owen’s credibility has faced scrutiny in other legal proceedings. A judge dismissed a different murder case involving Owen last year after he failed to share information about the victim’s prior suicide threats with prosecutors and the defense. Owen retired from the state division in 2024, shortly after receiving an honor for his service.

Murdaugh, 58, continues to deny killing Maggie and Paul Murdaugh at their Lowcountry estate. He is currently incarcerated for embezzling millions from his law practice and clients. He has admitted to theft, insurance fraud, and professional misconduct, while maintaining his innocence in the double homicide.

More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Central Wire Live in your inboxThe latest from the cities that shape the country. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Get Central Wire Live in your inboxThe latest from the cities that shape the country. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.