New Mexico Fraud: $4,000 Stolen in Halloween Call
A one-hour phone conversation with a fake bank employee led to the theft of $4,000 from one resident's account.
By Marco Harris ·

Four thousand dollars vanished from a New Mexico bank account following a single phone call received on Halloween night. James Anderson received the call from a person claiming to be with the fraud department at First Financial Credit Union. The caller alerted Anderson to four suspicious transactions, each for $1,000. Anderson stated he believed the voice on the line belonged to his actual bank.
"I thought it for sure was my bank, but it wasn't," Anderson said. He remained on the line with the caller for approximately one hour. During that time, the scammer sent text messages and requested verification codes along with Anderson's account password. The fraudster successfully withdrew the money in four separate charges of $1,000 each.
"But yeah, they took first charge was a thousand, second charge was a thousand, third charge was a thousand. And the fourth charge was a thousand. So a total of $4,000 they scammed me out of," Anderson said.
Doubts arose later, prompting Anderson to visit his bank branch in person. While there, the scammer called again. A credit union employee asked the caller for a full name and specific employee information. Anderson instructed the caller to provide those details. The caller hung up immediately, ending the contact for good. "I said, 'Give her your information.' He hung up the phone. That was the last I've heard from him since," Anderson said.
Bank of America New Mexico market president Paul Mondragón noted that legitimate banks rarely ask for information they should already possess. He advised customers to view requests for account details as a potential sign of fraud. Mondragón also pointed to unusual payment methods and misspelled email addresses or URLs as key warning signs. "So always double check the e-mail or the URL. Make sure there's not something funky in there or they've changed, say, one for an I or vice versa," Mondragón said.
Anderson filed a police report regarding the incident. His bank indicated he may receive a refund within a few days. Statewide, the Federal Trade Commission has recorded more than 6,000 fraud reports in New Mexico for 2026, with total losses exceeding $35 million.






