2027 Baseball Hall of Fame Ballot Features Buster Posey and Chase Utley as Key Candidates
The 2027 Hall of Fame ballot features Buster Posey and Chase Utley as top contenders, alongside 13 holdovers and 14 other newcomers.
By Marco Harris ·

The Baseball Writers' Association of America released its ballot for the 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame vote on Monday, November 16, 2026. The list includes 13 holdovers and 14 newcomers, totaling 27 players. Among the returning candidates are veterans like Alex Rodriguez and Chase Utley, while new additions include Giants legend Buster Posey and former pitcher Jon Lester. The full roster also features names such as Mark Buehrle, Cole Hamels, and Felix Hernandez, reflecting a mix of recent stars and long-time contenders.
To secure induction in the 2027 class, players must receive votes from at least 75 percent of the ballots cast. Those who gather at least 5 percent of the vote remain eligible for the following year, allowing them up to 10 cycles on the ballot. Players who fail to meet these thresholds fall off the list, though the doors to the Hall are not permanently closed. The results of this year's vote are scheduled for announcement on January 19, with the induction ceremony planned for the summer in Cooperstown.
This offseason features two distinct voting processes. The BBWAA vote covers former players who have been retired for at least five years. Separately, the Era Committees are evaluating candidates who did not succeed through the BBWAA route. This year, the Contemporary Baseball Committee is focused on non-players, including managers, umpires, and executives whose impact was realized since 1980. Notable names on that committee ballot include Sandy Alderson, Dusty Baker, and Bruce Bochy. The vote for these committee selections is set for December 6.
Buster Posey is widely viewed as the strongest candidate for first-ballot induction. Although his career spanned only parts of 12 MLB seasons, his overall impact and legacy suggest he will meet the 75 percent threshold. Jon Lester is considered the next most viable newcomer, though he faces a difficult path. Other first-time candidates, including Brett Gardner, Ryan Zimmerman, and Kyle Seager, are expected to struggle to reach the 5 percent retention mark, potentially making them one-year candidates.
Alex Rodriguez is in his sixth year on the ballot. His career statistics place him among the top position players historically, but performance-enhancing drug associations have slowed his progress. His support rose from 37.1 percent in 2025 to 40 percent in the most recent cycle. While this is a personal best, the increase is modest. A significant jump into the 50 percent range would be required to change the trajectory of his candidacy.
Chase Utley presents a compelling case for induction in his fourth year on the ballot. His support has grown steadily, moving from 28.8 percent in his first year to 59.1 percent in the previous cycle. With 15.9 percent needed to reach the 75 percent mark, and a relatively weak field of first-time candidates, Utley has a strong opportunity to secure his place in the Hall this year or establish a path to induction in 2028.
The standing of several holdover starting pitchers remains a point of discussion. Andy Pettitte received 48.5 percent of the vote in his eighth attempt, showing significant growth from his initial 9.9 percent. Felix Hernandez, who jumped to 46.1 percent in his second year, is trending toward induction. Cole Hamels is in his second year with 23.8 percent support, while Mark Buehrle has reached 20 percent in his seventh year after years of low single-digit support.
Reliever Francisco Rodriguez, known as K-Rod, is in his fourth year on the ballot. He has received between 7.8 percent and 11.8 percent of the vote so far. His progress is being watched closely by analysts tracking active relievers like Kenley Jansen, Craig Kimbrel, and Aroldis Chapman. If Rodriguez continues to struggle, it may indicate a high bar for future relief pitcher candidates.
Other holdovers show varied fortunes. Bobby Abreu received 30.8 percent in his seventh try, while Jimmy Rollins garnered 25.4 percent in his fifth. Dustin Pedroia is in his second year with 20.7 percent support. Omar Vizquel is on his final, 10th ballot with 18.4 percent of the vote. David Wright received 14.8 percent in his third year, and Torii Hunter remains just above the 5 percent cutoff with 8.7 percent in his sixth attempt.
Predictions for the 2027 class point to Buster Posey and Chase Utley as the likely inductees via the BBWAA vote. Posey is considered a lock due to his legacy, while Utley's steady rise on a less competitive ballot favors his selection. The committee vote for non-players will be analyzed separately, with potential selections adding further diversity to the Hall's recent inductees.
More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?






